
LA PAZ, Bolivia — For more than four decades, Silvia Rivera Cusicanqui has made a career of saying unwelcome things to people who expected her applause.
She told Bolivia’s white and mestizo elites that their republic was a colony in disguise. She told the international left that the Indigenous government of Evo Morales, which much of the world had hailed as a historic break, was betraying the people it claimed to represent. And she told the fashionable academics of “decolonial theory” in North American universities that they were profiting from ideas taken from the Andes while leaving the Andes out of the conversation.
Born in 1949 and now an emeritus professor of sociology at the Universidad Mayor de San Andrés, the public university in La Paz, Ms. Rivera Cusicanqui is widely regarded as one of the most original thinkers in Latin America. An Aymara feminist, historian and activist, she has worked alongside the Katarista Indigenous movement and Bolivia’s coca growers, and her ideas now circulate from São Paulo to Barcelona. This year an Argentine university series devoted to the great thinkers of Latin America added a volume on her, placing her in a canon she has spent her life questioning.
Her central idea is captured in a single Aymara word, ch’ixi: a gray that, seen up close, turns out to be made of black and white specks that never blend. Bolivia, she argues, is like that. So are its people, and so, perhaps, is the modern world.
A Mixed Inheritance
Ms. Rivera Cusicanqui was born in La Paz, the daughter of Carlos Rivera and Gabriela Cusicanqui, in a family whose Aymara and European roots mirrored the divisions of the country around it. Bolivia had just passed through the 1952 revolution, which gave land and the vote to Indigenous peasants but also pressed them to become “campesinos” and mestizos, shedding their Indian identity in the name of the nation.
She trained as a sociologist at San Andrés and came of age during the military regimes of the 1960s and 1970s, when Latin American universities were battlegrounds and many of the region’s intellectuals were driven into exile. It was the era that sent Isabel Allende fleeing Chile after the 1973 coup and that Eduardo Galeano chronicled in Open Veins of Latin America, his 1971 account of a continent bled for five centuries.
She has often said that her own mixed identity is the starting point of her work, not an embarrassment to be resolved. A critic once mocked her as a “sochóloga,” a slur fusing sociologist and chola, the term for urban Indigenous women. She adopted the insult as a badge.
History From the Mouths of the Defeated
In 1983, as Bolivia emerged from dictatorship, Ms. Rivera Cusicanqui and a group of Aymara and mestizo intellectuals founded the Taller de Historia Oral Andina, or Andean Oral History Workshop. The self-managed collective set out to record the memories of Aymara communities whose history had never been written down by anyone who spoke their language.
The following year produced two landmark books. The workshop published a collective study of Santos Marka T’ula, an Aymara leader who spent decades fighting in the courts for communal land. Ms. Rivera Cusicanqui published Oprimidos pero no vencidos (Oppressed but Not Defeated), a history of Aymara and Quechua peasant struggles from 1900 to 1980. The book argued that Indigenous rebellion in Bolivia was not a relic but a living tradition, and it became required reading for the Katarista movement and, later, for a generation of Indigenous activists.
For Ms. Rivera Cusicanqui, oral history was never just a technique. In a 1990 essay she argued that when Aymara elders tell their own past, they do not simply supply data to scholars; they challenge who has the authority to interpret history. The work has a close kin in Mexico, where the historian Miguel Pastrana Flores has spent his career recovering Nahua accounts of the Spanish conquest. Both insist that the conquered had their own historians.
That insistence also unsettles older stories about how Europeans won. Scholars like J.C. Sharman have shown that Spanish conquerors relied on Indigenous allies and local rulers far more than imperial legend admits, much as the scholarship on slavery and precolonial power discussed by Patrick Sheehy complicates the history of Africa. Ms. Rivera Cusicanqui’s Andes are likewise full of negotiation, resistance and survival, not merely defeat. In 2010, she and the collective El Colectivo explored that history in Principio Potosí Reverso, an exhibition project at the Reina Sofía museum in Madrid that turned the silver mines of Potosí, which financed Europe’s rise, into a lens on colonial labor and its afterlives.
The Colony That Never Ended
The backbone of her thought is the concept of internal colonialism, first formulated by the Mexican sociologist Pablo González Casanova in the 1960s. Ms. Rivera Cusicanqui took the idea and gave it historical depth. In essays from the early 1990s, she described Bolivia as layered by three historical horizons: the colonial order of the Spanish empire, the liberal republic of the 19th century and the populist nationalism of the 1952 revolution. Each promised inclusion, she argued, and each reproduced the colonial line between Indians and everyone else in new form.
Liberal reforms, in her account, offered Indigenous people a conditional, second-class citizenship, while the 1952 revolution invited them to become equal by ceasing to be Indian. The argument recalls Frantz Fanon, who described how the colonized are pushed to wear the mask of the colonizer, and Edward Said, who showed how empire manufactures its images of the people it rules. It also resembles Achille Mbembe‘s portrait of the African postcolony, where independence repainted colonial power rather than removing it.
She has been pointed about intellectual credit. She has noted that González Casanova’s work on internal colonialism appeared in 1969, while later stars of decolonial theory were still committed to a linear, positivist Marxism, and that the debt is rarely acknowledged.
Ch’ixi: Living With Contradiction
Her best-known concept arrived in Ch’ixinakax utxiwa (2010), a short book whose title, in Aymara, means roughly “there are ch’ixi people.” An English translation by Molly Geidel was published by Polity in 2020.
The word describes a color, or a stone, that looks gray from afar but is made of contrasting specks that never fuse. Ms. Rivera Cusicanqui offers it as an alternative to the official Latin American ideal of mestizaje, which imagined races melting into a harmonious national blend, and to the cultural theorist Néstor García Canclini’s notion of hybridity. Ch’ixi, by contrast, names a mixture in which opposites coexist without resolving, what she calls the logic of the included third.
The concept speaks across the Professor Press canon. It answers Kwame Anthony Appiah‘s cosmopolitan hope that identities can be loosened and shared, with a reminder that some differences are lived as ongoing tension, not dissolved. It resonates with Judith Butler‘s argument that identities are performed and never fixed. And it complements Julian Go‘s call for a postcolonial sociology that sees the colonized not as passive objects but as producers of the modern world.
A Sociology of Images
Ms. Rivera Cusicanqui distrusts words, especially in a country where Spanish has long served to hide as much as it reveals. Her Sociología de la imagen (2015) proposes reading colonial history through pictures. Her favorite source is Felipe Guaman Poma de Ayala, the Andean chronicler whose illustrated letter to the Spanish king, finished around 1615, depicted the abuses of colonial priests, magistrates and landlords. In his drawings, she argues, an Indigenous author said in images what he could not safely say in prose. She has also carried the method into her own documentary and fiction films.
Against the Decolonial Industry
Few Latin American intellectuals have been as blunt about the politics of their own field. In Ch’ixinakax utxiwa, Ms. Rivera Cusicanqui accused prominent decolonial scholars based in the United States, above all the Duke University semiotician Walter Mignolo, of taking ideas developed in Andean struggles, stripping them of their politics and repackaging them as theory for Northern classrooms. She went as far as to say that such scholars were building an empire within an empire.
The problem, she argued, was not only one of citation. Rather than the “geopolitics of knowledge” favored by decolonial theorists, she proposed studying the political economy of knowledge: the salaries, fellowships, degrees and citation networks through which Northern universities turn Southern thought into academic capital. Her remedy was practical. She urged scholars to write in their own languages, publish with small independent presses and build horizontal conversations among researchers in the South.
That critique sits beside, and sometimes against, the work of Boaventura de Sousa Santos, with whom she has debated publicly. Both call for an ecology of knowledges that takes non-Western thought seriously. But where Mr. Santos built large institutions and international networks, Ms. Rivera Cusicanqui has preferred small, self-managed collectives, a habit that reflects her long engagement with Andean anarchist and artisan traditions, which she studied in Los artesanos libertarios y la ética del trabajo (1988), written with Zulema Lehm.
Breaking With Evo Morales
When Evo Morales, an Aymara coca grower’s leader, became Bolivia’s first Indigenous president in 2006, much of the global left celebrated. Ms. Rivera Cusicanqui soon became one of his sharpest critics from below.
The breaking point came in 2011, when the government pushed a highway through the Isiboro Sécure Indigenous Territory and National Park, known as TIPNIS. Lowland Indigenous groups marched hundreds of miles to La Paz in protest, and in September police raided their camp at Chaparina. In Mito y desarrollo en Bolivia: El giro colonial del gobierno del MAS (2014), she argued that Morales’s Movement for Socialism had used Indigenous symbols to legitimize the same extractive model of development that colonial and republican governments had imposed. She returned to the episode in a long 2018 essay recalling the march as a struggle for dignity.
The position put her at odds with admirers of Bolivia’s “process of change,” including the Argentine political scientist Atilio Borón, a prominent defender of the region’s progressive governments. It placed her closer to critics of extractivism such as Aviva Chomsky, whose work on Colombian coal and Latin American labor traces how mining and export economies displace Indigenous and rural communities.
Women, Coca and the Market
Gender runs through all of it. Ms. Rivera Cusicanqui has written extensively about Aymara market women and about how both colonial law and modern legal reform defined Indigenous women out of rights. In a 1997 essay on the “paradoxes of postcolonial modernity,” she examined how the language of rights could leave Indigenous women and men worse off by forcing them into categories built for others.
The argument parallels Rita Laura Segato‘s analysis of how colonial modernity intensified patriarchy in Indigenous communities. Her study of coca, Las fronteras de la coca (2003), likewise challenged the war on drugs by treating the coca leaf as a sacred and economic good of Andean peoples rather than a narcotic, a view that echoes Noam Chomsky‘s long critique of US drug policy in Latin America as an instrument of power.
A Thinker for a Speckled World
Ms. Rivera Cusicanqui’s influence has grown as her work has crossed languages. Her books now appear in Portuguese, English and German. Students in Brazil, Argentina and Mexico read her alongside Fanon and Galeano. In Buenos Aires, seminars on her methods have drawn more than a hundred students at a time.
She belongs to a long Latin American tradition of thinking from the margins that the Argentine philosopher Hugo Biagini has spent decades documenting, a tradition of “alternative thought” that refuses to treat Europe as the measure of all ideas. Her critique of development as a colonial myth runs parallel to Ha-Joon Chang‘s argument that rich nations prescribe to poor ones policies they never followed themselves, though she goes further in questioning whether growth should be the goal at all.
Her defense of the Indian as modern rather than folkloric shares ground with Jorge Majfud, whose histories of Anglo-American expansion and essays on Indigenous democracy challenge the myth that the colonized had no political traditions of their own. Her concern for the dignity of the poor and the excluded echoes the ethics of Adela Cortina, who coined the term aporophobia to name the rejection of the poor. And her portraits of rural Bolivia, haunted by bosses, ghosts and unspoken violence, have a literary relative in Juan Rulfo‘s Pedro Páramo, where the dead of Comala still murmur about the cacique who owned their land.
She also fits within a global conversation about colonialism and its afterlives. Like the Guyanese historian Walter Rodney, she treated the history of the poor as a weapon in present struggles. Like Rashid Khalidi and Noura Erakat, who have documented how law and history are used to dispossess Palestinians, she has examined how legal systems built for settlers turned Indigenous people into strangers on their own land. And as governments across the region, Bolivia included, surveil activists and shut down communication during protests, the research of Kris Ruijgrok on digital authoritarianism describes a newer frontier of the control she has studied for decades.
Her critics say her style can be elusive and her hostility to academic institutions sometimes overstated, given that her own work circulates through them. She would likely accept the contradiction. That, after all, is what ch’ixi means: two things held together, neither one erased.
At a moment when debates over identity, migration and Indigenous rights are sharpening from the Andes to the Amazon, her central claim feels less like theory than description. Colonialism, she argues, did not end with independence, and decolonization will not arrive by decree from a presidential palace or a university seminar. It must be practiced, she insists, in daily life, in language and in the way people remember.
Bibliography
Books
Rivera Cusicanqui, Silvia. Oprimidos pero no vencidos: Luchas del campesinado aymara y qhechwa, 1900–1980. La Paz, 1984; reissued by La Mirada Salvaje, 2010.
Lehm, Zulema, and Silvia Rivera Cusicanqui. Los artesanos libertarios y la ética del trabajo. La Paz: Gramma, 1988.
Rivera Cusicanqui, Silvia. Las fronteras de la coca: Epistemologías coloniales y circuitos alternativos de la hoja de coca. La Paz: IDIS-UMSA / Aruwiyiri, 2003.
Rivera Cusicanqui, Silvia. Ch’ixinakax utxiwa: Una reflexión sobre prácticas y discursos descolonizadores. Buenos Aires: Tinta Limón, 2010.
Rivera Cusicanqui, Silvia, and El Colectivo. Principio Potosí Reverso. Madrid: Museo Nacional Centro de Arte Reina Sofía, 2010.
Rivera Cusicanqui, Silvia. Mito y desarrollo en Bolivia: El giro colonial del gobierno del MAS. La Paz: Piedra Rota / Plural, 2014.
Rivera Cusicanqui, Silvia. Sociología de la imagen: Miradas ch’ixi desde la historia andina. Buenos Aires: Tinta Limón, 2015.
Rivera Cusicanqui, Silvia. Un mundo ch’ixi es posible: Ensayos desde un presente en crisis. Buenos Aires: Tinta Limón, 2018.
Rivera Cusicanqui, Silvia. Ch’ixinakax utxiwa: On Practices and Discourses of Decolonisation. Translated by Molly Geidel. Cambridge: Polity, 2020.
Selected Articles and Essays
Rivera Cusicanqui, Silvia. “El potencial epistemológico y teórico de la historia oral: De la lógica instrumental a la descolonización de la historia.” Temas Sociales, no. 11, 1990, pp. 49–75.
Rivera Cusicanqui, Silvia. “La noción de ‘derecho’ o las paradojas de la modernidad postcolonial: Indígenas y mujeres en Bolivia.” Temas Sociales, no. 19, 1997.
Rivera Cusicanqui, Silvia. “Ch’ixinakax utxiwa: A Reflection on the Practices and Discourses of Decolonization.” South Atlantic Quarterly, vol. 111, no. 1, 2012, pp. 95–109.
Rivera Cusicanqui, Silvia. “TIPNIS: La larga marcha por nuestra dignidad.” Cuestión Agraria, vol. 4, 2018, pp. 7–38.
About Her
Garino, Agustina, and Jorgelina Loza. Silvia Rivera Cusicanqui: La artesana intelectual. Los Polvorines: Universidad Nacional de General Sarmiento, 2026.
Sources
- Garino and Loza, Silvia Rivera Cusicanqui: la artesana intelectual (UNGS, 2026)
- Global Social Theory: Silvia Rivera Cusicanqui
- MACBA: Beyond Pain and Folklore lecture
- University of New Mexico LAII lecture announcement, 2014
- Fundación Tierra, Cuestión Agraria vol. 4 (TIPNIS)
- Cuadernos de Historia: THOA and Rivera Cusicanqui, 1983–1984
- Gandolfi Ottavianelli, “Subalternidad e historia oral en Bolivia”
- Torres Guillén on González Casanova and internal colonialism (Redalyc)
- University of Michigan Crossroads: ch’ixi and anthropology
- UT Austin E3W review of the South Atlantic Quarterly essay
- Jungle World review of the German edition
- Herder: author page
- Viewpoint Magazine
- Polity edition of Ch’ixinakax utxiwa (2020)
Leave a Reply