Mahmood Mamdani: Colonial Power, Political Identity and the Unfinished Work of Decolonization

Mahmood Mamdani
Mahmood Mamdani

Few thinkers have accomplished as much as Mahmood Mamdani to illuminate why the close of colonial rule did not bring the collapse of colonial power. A Ugandan political theorist and anthropologist, a former exile and a twice-denationalised citizen, Mamdani has devoted more than half a century to probing a deceptively simple question: how did empire succeed in outlasting itself? His response, elaborated across a dozen volumes, is that colonialism administered not only territory and labour but identity itself, dividing subjects into “settlers” and “natives”, tribes and races, majorities and enduring minorities. Postcolonial states inherited those classifications, and with them the violence they enabled.

Now eighty and still teaching at Columbia University, Mamdani belongs to a lineage that runs from Frantz Fanon and Walter Rodney through Edward Said and Achille Mbembe. Yet his voice is unmistakably his own: empirical where others are speculative, institutional where others are cultural, and stubbornly focused on the political as the site where history is made and can be unmade.

Early Life and Education

Mahmood Mamdani was born on 23 April 1946 in Bombay, then part of British India, and raised in Kampala within Uganda’s Gujarati Muslim community. His childhood unfolded in a late-colonial society organised by race: Europeans at the top, Asians in the middle as traders and clerks, Africans at the bottom. That three-tiered order, which he lived before he theorised it, became the raw material of his scholarship.

In 1963, on the eve of Ugandan independence, he was one of 23 Ugandan students flown to the United States on scholarship. He graduated from the University of Pittsburgh in 1967, and the American civil rights movement gave him his first political education. He joined the Freedom Rides to the South and was briefly jailed in Montgomery, Alabama, an episode he has described as formative in linking the struggle against Jim Crow to the struggle against colonialism.

He went on to graduate study at the Fletcher School at Tufts and then to Harvard, where he completed a doctorate in government in 1974 under Karl Deutsch. His dissertation, Politics and Class Formation in Uganda, already announced the method that would define his career: a refusal to treat African politics as a story of tribes and culture, and an insistence on tracing how colonial institutions produced the groups that later fought over the state.

Expulsion and Exile

Mamdani returned to Uganda in early 1972 to teach at Makerere University. Within months, Idi Amin ordered the expulsion of Uganda’s Asian population, and Mamdani found himself stateless, living in a refugee camp in London. He turned the experience into his first book, From Citizen to Refugee (1973), a firsthand account of what it means to be stripped of belonging by a postcolonial state.

Like Isabel Allende, whose life was upended by the Chilean coup of 1973, Mamdani’s intellectual identity was forged in the exile produced by a 1970s dictatorship. And like Allende, he would return to that rupture decades later, writing his country’s story through the lens of his own displacement.

Academic Career

Mamdani’s career has moved between East Africa, Southern Africa and North America, but its centre of gravity has always been the African university. From 1973 to 1979 he taught at the University of Dar es Salaam in Tanzania, then the most vibrant intellectual hub on the continent. The “Dar es Salaam school” was arguing over socialism, dependency and the class character of the postcolonial state, and Walter Rodney, whose How Europe Underdeveloped Africa had appeared in 1972, was still teaching there when Mamdani arrived.

After Amin’s fall in 1979 he returned to Makerere, only to clash with Milton Obote’s second government, which stripped him of his citizenship in the mid-1980s. Once Obote was overthrown he came home again in 1986. In 1987 he founded the Centre for Basic Research in Kampala, an independent institute meant to keep critical social science alive outside the reach of governments and donors.

In 1996 he became the inaugural A. C. Jordan Professor of African Studies at the University of Cape Town. His time there ended in a public dispute, the so-called “Mamdani affair”, after he criticised a foundation course that, in his view, taught Africa through apartheid-era assumptions and treated South Africa as an exception to the continent. Decades later, UCT’s Centre for African Studies named him an honorary professor, a gesture widely read as institutional repair.

Since 1999 he has been at Columbia University, where he is Herbert Lehman Professor of Government and Professor of Anthropology and of Middle Eastern, South Asian, and African Studies. He served as president of CODESRIA, the Council for the Development of Social Science Research in Africa, from 1998 to 2002, a period that overlapped with Achille Mbembe’s tenure as its executive secretary. From 2010 to 2022 he directed the Makerere Institute of Social Research, rebuilding it as an interdisciplinary doctoral programme grounded in African questions, and in 2021 he became chancellor of Kampala International University.

Core Ideas and Theoretical Contributions

At the heart of Mamdani’s work lies a single conviction: political identities are made, not found. Race and tribe are not primordial facts that politics merely reflects; they are legal and administrative categories that the colonial state invented, enforced and passed on. To understand violence in the postcolony, one must therefore read the law books before the ethnographies.

Decentralised Despotism

Citizen and Subject (1996), which won the African Studies Association’s Herskovits Award, is the cornerstone of this project. Mamdani argues that colonial Africa was governed through a bifurcated state. In the towns, a minority of settlers and “civilised” Africans lived under civil law as citizens with rights. In the countryside, the majority lived as subjects under “customary” law, administered by chiefs whom the colonial power appointed and armed. He calls this system decentralised despotism: indirect rule dressed as tradition.

The insight is devastating for both nationalist and liberal accounts of Africa. Independence deracialised the cities but left the rural apparatus of chiefly power largely intact, so that the postcolonial state reproduced the very division it claimed to overcome. Here Mamdani extends Fanon’s warning in The Wretched of the Earth about the pitfalls of national consciousness, giving it an institutional anatomy.

The argument also speaks across oceans. Juan Rulfo‘s Pedro Páramo, the cacique who owns the land, the law and the people of Comala, is a literary portrait of exactly the kind of local despotism Mamdani found sheltered under the label of custom. And Rita Laura Segato‘s analysis of how colonial modernity hardened and intensified pre-existing patriarchies runs parallel to Mamdani’s demonstration that “customary” law was often a colonial codification that empowered male chiefs at the expense of women and youth.

The Native as a Political Identity

In Define and Rule: Native as Political Identity (2012), Mamdani traces the intellectual origins of indirect rule to the aftermath of the 1857 Indian rebellion, when British administrators such as Henry Maine concluded that empire should stop trying to civilise its subjects and instead govern them through their supposed traditions. The “native” was thereby defined as a being of custom, frozen in a tribal past, while the settler alone possessed history.

This comparative, imperial-scale perspective links Mamdani to Julian Go, whose postcolonial sociology insists that empires must be studied as connected systems rather than national stories. It also complements J.C. Sharman‘s work on how small European powers ruled through local intermediaries, and the scholarship on precolonial African political power and the slave trade discussed by Patrick Sheehy, which reminds us that the colonial “tradition” Mamdani dissects was itself a selective rewriting of a complex African past. In the Americas, Miguel Pastrana Flores‘s recovery of indigenous memories of the conquest performs a similar task: restoring history to peoples whom empire defined as having only custom.

When Victims Become Killers

When Victims Become Killers (2001) applied this framework to the 1994 Rwandan genocide. Rejecting accounts that blamed ancient ethnic hatred, Mamdani showed that Belgian colonialism had turned Hutu and Tutsi into racialised legal identities, with Tutsi classified as alien “Hamites” and Hutu as indigenous natives. The genocide, he argued, was the work of people who understood themselves as natives defending the nation against a settler minority. Its logic was political, and so was its potential remedy.

Good Muslim, Bad Muslim

After 11 September 2001, Mamdani turned his method toward the United States. Good Muslim, Bad Muslim: America, the Cold War, and the Roots of Terror (2004) rejected “culture talk”, the habit of explaining political violence through Islam, and traced modern jihadist networks to Cold War proxy wars, especially Washington’s sponsorship of the Afghan mujahideen in the 1980s.

The book carries forward Edward Said’s critique of Orientalism and his warnings in Covering Islam, and it shares much with Noam Chomsky‘s dissection of US foreign policy. It also resonates with Judith Butler‘s Precarious Life, which asked, in the same years, whose lives the war on terror made grievable. Mamdani continued the argument in Saviors and Survivors (2009), a sharp critique of the Save Darfur campaign that questioned how Western humanitarian language can depoliticise conflicts and license intervention.

Neither Settler nor Native

Neither Settler nor Native: The Making and Unmaking of Permanent Minorities (2020) is Mamdani’s most ambitious synthesis. It argues that the modern nation-state and colonialism were born together, and that both work by creating permanent majorities and permanent minorities. Ranging across the United States and its Native nations, Nazi Germany and the Nuremberg trials, South Africa, Sudan and Israel-Palestine, the book proposes that decolonisation means dismantling the political distinction between settler and native itself.

His chapter on Palestine places him in direct conversation with Rashid Khalidi, his colleague at Columbia, and with Noura Erakat, whose legal scholarship shows how law has been used both to entrench and to contest settler-colonial rule. His treatment of the American frontier finds an echo in Jorge Majfud‘s histories of Anglo-American expansion and its fanaticism toward Indigenous peoples and Latin America. And his answer, that survivors and perpetrators must learn to share a political community, stands as a pointed counterproposal to Kwame Anthony Appiah‘s liberal cosmopolitanism: where Appiah urges us to loosen the grip of identities, Mamdani insists we must first dismantle the institutions that keep producing them.

Major Works

Saviors and Survivors. Darfur, Politics, and the War on Terror by Mahmood Mamdani

Mamdani’s early books belong to the political economy tradition of the 1970s. The Myth of Population Control (1972), based on fieldwork in an Indian village, argued that poor families had many children not out of ignorance but because children were their only security, a direct challenge to Western-funded family planning programmes. Politics and Class Formation in Uganda (1976) and Imperialism and Fascism in Uganda (1983) read Ugandan history through class and empire, in the spirit of Rodney and of Eduardo Galeano, whose Open Veins of Latin America (1971) told the parallel story of a continent’s wealth drained outward.

The mature work then follows a clear arc: Citizen and Subject (1996) on the colonial state, When Victims Become Killers (2001) on genocide, Good Muslim, Bad Muslim (2004) and Saviors and Survivors (2009) on the war on terror and humanitarian intervention, Define and Rule (2012) on the intellectual history of indirect rule, and Neither Settler nor Native (2020) on the nation-state as a colonial form.

Slow Poison

His most recent book, Slow Poison: Idi Amin, Yoweri Museveni, and the Making of the Ugandan State, was published by Harvard University Press’s Belknap imprint on 14 October 2025. It returns to the place where his scholarship began. Part history and part memoir, it asks readers to set aside the Western caricature of Idi Amin as a buffoonish tyrant and to see both Amin and his eventual successor, Yoweri Museveni, as products of an unfinished decolonisation.

Mamdani recalls that Amin seized power in 1971 with the backing of Britain and Israel, and argues that Museveni, long celebrated in Washington as a new kind of African leader, re-created a version of colonial indirect rule by fragmenting Uganda’s majority into multiple ethnic minorities. The “slow poison” of the title is that colonial habit of turning ethnicity into territory and territory into a weapon of rule, refined by each post-independence regime. Through 2026 Mamdani has carried the book across Africa and beyond, with launches in Mombasa and Nairobi, a dialogue at the University of the Witwatersrand and the African Studies Centre’s annual lecture at Oxford.

The Public Intellectual and the Decolonised University

Mamdani has never separated scholarship from the institutions that make it possible. In Scholars in the Marketplace (2007) he documented what happened to Makerere University under World Bank-backed neoliberal reform between 1989 and 2005: the commercialisation of courses, the collapse of research and the turning of a public university into a fee-driven degree market. The study belongs alongside Ha-Joon Chang‘s critique of structural adjustment in Kicking Away the Ladder, which showed that rich countries prescribed to the South the very free-market policies they had avoided on their own way up.

His answer was to build. At the Centre for Basic Research, at CODESRIA and later at the Makerere Institute of Social Research, he worked to create spaces where Africans could produce knowledge about Africa on their own terms, rather than serve as data collectors for Northern consultancies. That project mirrors Boaventura de Sousa Santos‘s call for an ecology of knowledges and his critique of the colonial university in Decolonising the University. It also has a Latin American twin in CLACSO, the regional social science council long led by Atilio Borón, and in the history of alternative Latin American thought recovered by Hugo Biagini. CODESRIA and CLACSO, born of the same South-South impulse, are the institutional proof that the periphery can think for itself.

Citizenship, Refugees and Belonging

Having been a refugee himself, Mamdani has returned again and again to the question of who belongs. His insistence that citizenship should rest on residence rather than ancestry, and that “indigeneity” can become a weapon against migrants and minorities, places him close to Aviva Chomsky, whose work on undocumented migration exposes how states manufacture illegality. It also echoes Adela Cortina‘s concept of aporophobia, the rejection of the poor that so often hides behind the language of rejecting foreigners.

A Voice Beyond the Academy

Mamdani has long written for wide audiences, in the London Review of Books, in newspapers across Africa and in interviews with outlets such as Democracy Now!. In 2008 Foreign Policy and Prospect named him among the world’s leading public intellectuals. His blunt exchanges with Uganda’s rulers are part of the legend: asked by Museveni why a professor was always talking, Mamdani, by his own account, replied that he was paid to talk.

In an age when African governments routinely shut down the internet during elections and protests, that commitment to speech has new stakes. The work of Kris Ruijgrok on digital authoritarianism and online resistance describes the newest instruments of the state power that Mamdani has spent his life analysing.

Legacy and Influence

Few books in African studies have been cited, taught and argued over as much as Citizen and Subject. The concept of decentralised despotism has become standard vocabulary for historians of indirect rule, political scientists studying chieftaincy and land, and policymakers debating customary law. When Victims Become Killers remains a central text in genocide studies, and Good Muslim, Bad Muslim gave a generation of readers a vocabulary, “culture talk”, for resisting the post-2001 consensus.

His influence is also personal and institutional. Through MISR’s doctoral programme he trained a cohort of African scholars to take the continent’s intellectual history as seriously as Europe’s, and through CODESRIA he helped sustain a pan-African community of researchers through the lean years of structural adjustment. His recent public profile has grown further as the father of New York City mayor Zohran Mamdani, but the scholar’s reputation was secure long before the son’s election.

Critics have pushed back on parts of his work. Some historians argue that Citizen and Subject overstates the uniformity of colonial rule across Africa; some human rights advocates rejected his reading of Darfur; and his comparison of Israel with other settler states remains fiercely contested. Mamdani has typically welcomed such disputes as the ordinary business of scholarship.

An Enduring Urgency

In a world where majorities are again being defined by blood and soil, where refugees are recast as invaders and where wars are explained through the clash of cultures, Mamdani’s work reads less like history than diagnosis. His central lesson is that the categories through which we fight, native and settler, majority and minority, are not natural. They were built by laws and institutions, and what has been built can be rebuilt.

That conviction connects him to Fanon’s demand for a new humanism, to Rodney’s patient explanation of how Africa was made poor, to Said’s defence of the humanities against imperial certainties and to Mbembe’s critique of the postcolony. It places him, too, in conversation with Latin American thinkers from Galeano to Segato who have read their continent’s wounds through the same colonial lens. Few contemporary scholars have so consistently insisted that decolonisation is not a date in the past but a task still before us, and it is that insistence, sustained across five decades and three continents, that makes Mahmood Mamdani one of the indispensable intellectuals of our time.

Bibliography

Books

Mamdani, Mahmood. The Myth of Population Control: Family, Caste and Class in an Indian Village. Monthly Review Press, 1972.

Mamdani, Mahmood. From Citizen to Refugee: Uganda Asians Come to Britain. Frances Pinter, 1973.

Mamdani, Mahmood. Politics and Class Formation in Uganda. Monthly Review Press, 1976.

Mamdani, Mahmood. Imperialism and Fascism in Uganda. Heinemann, 1983.

Mamdani, Mahmood. Citizen and Subject: Contemporary Africa and the Legacy of Late Colonialism. Princeton University Press, 1996.

Mamdani, Mahmood. When Victims Become Killers: Colonialism, Nativism, and the Genocide in Rwanda. Princeton University Press, 2001.

Mamdani, Mahmood. Good Muslim, Bad Muslim: America, the Cold War, and the Roots of Terror. Pantheon, 2004.

Mamdani, Mahmood. Scholars in the Marketplace: The Dilemmas of Neo-Liberal Reform at Makerere University, 1989–2005. CODESRIA, 2007.

Mamdani, Mahmood. Saviors and Survivors: Darfur, Politics, and the War on Terror. Pantheon, 2009.

Mamdani, Mahmood. Define and Rule: Native as Political Identity. Harvard University Press, 2012.

Mamdani, Mahmood. Neither Settler nor Native: The Making and Unmaking of Permanent Minorities. Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, 2020.

Mamdani, Mahmood. Slow Poison: Idi Amin, Yoweri Museveni, and the Making of the Ugandan State. Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, 2025.

Selected Articles and Essays

Mamdani, Mahmood. “Beyond Settler and Native as Political Identities: Overcoming the Political Legacy of Colonialism.” Comparative Studies in Society and History, vol. 43, no. 4, 2001, pp. 651–664.

Mamdani, Mahmood. “Good Muslim, Bad Muslim: A Political Perspective on Culture and Terrorism.” American Anthropologist, vol. 104, no. 3, 2002, pp. 766–775.

Mamdani, Mahmood. “The Politics of Naming: Genocide, Civil War, Insurgency.” London Review of Books, vol. 29, no. 5, 2007.

Mamdani, Mahmood. “Settler Colonialism: Then and Now.” Critical Inquiry, vol. 41, no. 3, 2015, pp. 596–614.

Sources

Blogroll


Mysteries by Rose
Mysteries by Rose
Blog by Author C.F. Grönroos

chump lady
chump lady
Leave a cheater, gain a life!

Ukraine Today .org
Ukraine Today .org
Since 2019

Deadline
Deadline
Hollywood Entertainment Breaking News

Leave a Reply